Feed selection of syndication plugin
Posted: Mon Jun 09, 2014 8:27 pm
I mentioned this in http://board.s9y.org/viewtopic.php?f=4&t=19956.
There are a number of feed-formats I don't think we should support any longer in the plugin. These are:
RSS 0.91
RSS 1.0
Atom 0.3
opml1.0*
I would like to remove these, at least from the snydication plugin option list, but also from the core where it seems hasslefree to do so. Is anyone here still using these and would have an issue with that? Garvin, do you know of existing usecases?
The remaining selection would be:
RSS 2
Atom 1.0
and the same for comments
--------------------
One could probably also argue for the removal of Atom 1.0, and rather have it as switch (to either list an Atom or a RSS feed). I would like this and think this should mean no problem for no one, as the current readers should all support both, but it is nothing that has to be done. But we could then change the plugin html to not be a generic list, but be either an entry feed (RSS or Atom, and subtome using) and an optional comment feed (RSS or Atom) button, that could be quite nice. Maybe with fitting icons and all.
Opinions on this?
*Note that OPML really should stay supported in the core, it could be useful as an export/import format. I see just no place for it in a visitor-facing subscribe plugin.
There are a number of feed-formats I don't think we should support any longer in the plugin. These are:
RSS 0.91
RSS 1.0
Atom 0.3
opml1.0*
I would like to remove these, at least from the snydication plugin option list, but also from the core where it seems hasslefree to do so. Is anyone here still using these and would have an issue with that? Garvin, do you know of existing usecases?
The remaining selection would be:
RSS 2
Atom 1.0
and the same for comments
--------------------
One could probably also argue for the removal of Atom 1.0, and rather have it as switch (to either list an Atom or a RSS feed). I would like this and think this should mean no problem for no one, as the current readers should all support both, but it is nothing that has to be done. But we could then change the plugin html to not be a generic list, but be either an entry feed (RSS or Atom, and subtome using) and an optional comment feed (RSS or Atom) button, that could be quite nice. Maybe with fitting icons and all.
Opinions on this?
*Note that OPML really should stay supported in the core, it could be useful as an export/import format. I see just no place for it in a visitor-facing subscribe plugin.