Thanks! That was definitely the problem. Once I turned off the "Confirm Always" everything worked as it should.

Moderation emails come through now if moderation is on and notification emails come if moderation is off.

Hi!

When you leave the test comment, what kind of email gets send to the commentor with a confirmation link? The only mail that he could get would be a Double Opt In confirmation mail if he has checked the option "Subscribe to comments".
When doing the test comment I don't check the "Subscribe to ...

maybe you are logged in with your admin-account?
No, not logged in.

I meant to also include with my first post that when entering a comment it says at the bottom in red "Submitted comments will be subject to moderation before being displayed."

Then after submitting is says "Warning: This comment ...

I'm having trouble getting the comment moderation to work as well as be notified when a comment is left. I am using version 1.4.

I have "Send comment announcements" set to Yes. I have a personal email address set that works.

On the entry I have "Allow comments to this entry" checked and "Comments ...